Avid MC question
Posted 28 November 2008 - 02:06 PM
Is it true that you must have Avid's proprietary hardware (mojodx) for full 1920x1080 HD-SDI output to a calibrated monitor? Is MC not compatible with let's say an AJA card?
Are there any such problems w/ FCP?
Posted 21 December 2008 - 05:36 AM
yes I believe you are correct that to get full HD playback to a client monitor you will need the MOJO box
and no Avid is not compatible with AJA or other cards.
<Are there any such problems w/ FCP?>
yes, you will need a full HD card, AJA, Blackmagic etc for FCP in the same way you need a Mojo for the Avid, they're just hardware interfaces. If your editing full HD (not HDV) you will need a box or card to digitise the rushes. If you get a post house to digitise you can make do without the Mojo but playback is only on the computer desktop. (same with FCP)
If you are cutting full HD then FCP is by far the cheapest solution but Avid is the most reliable and to my mind most efficient.
Posted 21 December 2008 - 05:43 AM
Sorry, I meant to ask, if you are looking for NLE and DAW I think you would be hard pressed to find
a better partnership than Avid and Pro Tools. There are a ton of others but let's put it this way
If the project goes to s*@t and you need to get it done you just pick up your media drives and head to
the nearest post house and plug them in. Much harder to do with FCP and a bespoke DAW.
And no, I don't work for Avid but I do make my living as an editor and once burnt, never again...
Posted 21 December 2008 - 08:13 AM
Dunno if you're a student or not, but hell, if you are go for it. . .
I run both Avid and FCP over here and I can tell you while FCP is what I'm more used to (coming from premier) AVID is what I really prefer to cut on- and I'm not even an editor (just do it for some clients who request it-- simple things on lower budgets).
Only issue I have had with AVID was mixed time-base editing, e.g. 60i nd 24p do not play well together afaik in the MC.
Posted 24 December 2008 - 10:09 AM
The one problem is the standard 8200 configuration boots Windows XP from a SATA drive but Avid requires an EIDE/IDE boot drive. I got lucky and bought two 8200's which were coming off corporate lease and still in HP warranty until spring 2009. HP Support sent me out a full set of OEM disks including the XP system disk so all I had to do was pop in a 160GB EIDE drive and reload the HP copy of XP onto it. If all this is Computer-Babble to you, you'll need a buddy to understands computers to help you out.